Another well-known example for non-obviousness is the design shape of rectangles with rounded corners. This would be an even simpler example than the slide-to-unlock case. In this article from Foss patents, Apple claimed four major elements were copied by Samsung. The first element is described as "a flat, clear, black-colored, rectangular front surface with four evenly rounded corners". Sure, I'd agree this is a major component in Apple's design of a smartphone. But it shouldn't be treated as if Apple created the idea of having rectangular surface with rounded corners, resulting in Samsung stealing the idea.
Though rectangular rounded corners weren't the only element Apple claimed Samsung infringed on, the rest of the pieces were still very closely related to the detail of the rectangle shaped design. I would say arguing the obviousness of rectangular rounded corners would still make its case in the court if Apple wants to sue every smartphone manufacturer in the world who've made any rectangular rounded corner phone.
Maybe it's time for all the smartphone engineers to design a phone with sharp corners.
2014-04-27 updated with video
Maybe circular?
ReplyDeleteRae, you do a good job reviewing what we went over in class, and it's great to hear your opinions! Keep up the hard work!